Parking Space Rights: What Apartment Buyers Should Know
In Nahalchand Laloochand v Panchali CHS (2010), the Supreme Court held under Maharashtra's flat ownership law that stilt parking is a common area that the promoter cannot sell, though its cost can be shared among buyers by carpet area. Elsewhere your rights depend on state law and your agreement, so check exactly what parking the agreement allots and on what terms.
| Stilt parking under MOFA | Common area, "not sellable at all" by the promoter (Supreme Court, Nahalchand, 31 August 2010) |
|---|---|
| Common areas in UP | Cannot be transferred or partitioned; contrary covenants void (UP Apartment Act 2010, Section 5(4)) |
| Penalty in UP for selling common area land | 3 to 6 years' imprisonment, Rs 3 lakh to Rs 5 lakh fine, or both (Section 25(1)) |
| Changes to common areas | Need written consent of at least two-thirds of allottees (RERA Section 14(2)) |
| TDS on parking fee | Car parking fee is part of consideration for 1% property TDS (Income Tax Department) |
In this article
- What kinds of parking does a project usually offer?
- Can a builder sell you a stilt parking space?
- What do RERA and Uttar Pradesh law say about common areas?
- What should your agreement say about parking?
- Does a parking fee change your tax and duty?
- What if you buy a resale flat?
- What can you do in a parking dispute?
- Frequently asked questions
Parking causes more friction in apartment complexes than almost anything else, and many of those fights start with a line in the sale agreement that nobody read carefully. Before you pay for a slot, understand what the law in your state lets a builder sell, and what your agreement actually gives you.
What kinds of parking does a project usually offer?
Parking in a housing project generally falls into a few types: open surface parking in the compound, stilt parking under the building, basement or podium parking, and enclosed garages. The type matters because the law treats them differently.
Delhi's Unified Building Bye Laws 2016 give a useful definition. Clause 1.4.111 describes a stilt as a non-habitable portion of a building above ground level, with columns supporting the superstructure, open on at least two sides, and used for parking and landscaping. A stilt is part of the building, not a separate room.
Can a builder sell you a stilt parking space?
Not in Maharashtra, under the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963 (MOFA). In Nahalchand Laloochand Pvt Ltd v Panchali Co-operative Housing Society Ltd, decided on 31 August 2010, the Supreme Court held that a stilt parking space is neither a "flat" nor a "garage" (which it described as a place with a roof and walls on three sides). It is part of the common areas and facilities and "is not sellable at all" by the promoter.
The Court did not say parking is free. It held that the promoter may recover the cost of stilt parking as a common area, shared among flat purchasers in proportion to the carpet area of each flat, and that undertakings in purchase documents contrary to MOFA do not bind buyers.
Nahalchand interprets a Maharashtra statute. Buyers in other states should not assume it applies word for word, but it shows how courts look at parking: by asking whether the space is a separate unit or part of the common areas. If you are buying in Mumbai or Pune, the ruling applies directly to MOFA-governed buildings.
What do RERA and Uttar Pradesh law say about common areas?
RERA protects common areas in a general way. Section 11(4)(f) and Section 17(1) require the promoter to execute a registered conveyance in the buyer's favour along with the undivided proportionate title in the common areas, which goes to the association of allottees. Section 14(2) bars the promoter from altering sanctioned plans, layout plans or common areas without the written consent of at least two-thirds of the allottees, other than the promoter. That matters if a builder later tries to turn a green area into extra paid parking.
Uttar Pradesh is stricter. Under the UP Apartment (Promotion of Construction, Ownership and Maintenance) Act, 2010:
- Section 5(4): common areas and facilities cannot be transferred, remain undivided, no owner may seek their partition, and any contrary covenant is void.
- Section 25(1): a promoter who transfers land shown as common area in the approved plan faces imprisonment of three to six years, a fine of Rs 3 lakh to Rs 5 lakh, or both.
Buyers in Noida and Ghaziabad should therefore look hard at any clause that "sells" a slot carved out of common areas.
What should your agreement say about parking?
Read the parking clause in your allotment letter and builder-buyer agreement line by line. It should answer these questions clearly:
- What exactly is allotted: open, stilt, basement or garage, and how many slots.
- Where: a slot number marked on a parking plan attached to the agreement, not "a slot to be allotted later".
- On what basis: a right to use the slot, or ownership of it, and what happens to it when you sell the flat.
- At what price: whether parking is a separate charge, and whether that charge matches what your state's law permits.
- Who decides disputes later: the builder until handover, then the association or society under its bye-laws.
Our guide to the allotment letter and builder-buyer agreement covers the other clauses to check, and you can compare your draft against a standard builder-buyer agreement format on Legal Drive.
Does a parking fee change your tax and duty?
Yes. When a buyer deducts 1% TDS on a property purchase from a resident seller, the Income Tax Department's text of the provision counts incidental charges such as car parking fees, club membership fees, electricity or water facility fees and maintenance fees as part of the consideration. TDS applies when the consideration or stamp duty value is Rs 50 lakh or more, and from 1 April 2026 it falls under Section 393(1) Table Sl. No. 3(i) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (old Section 194-IA).
So a parking charge can push a purchase over the Rs 50 lakh threshold, and leaving it out of the TDS calculation means you deduct too little. Read more in TDS on property purchase.
What if you buy a resale flat?
Ask the seller to show the document that gave them their parking slot and confirm with the society or association that it recognises the allotment. If the slot was given as a right to use, find out whether the society's rules let it pass to a new owner. Make sure the sale deed describes the slot in the same words as the society's records.
What can you do in a parking dispute?
Before possession, your dispute is with the promoter. Section 31 of RERA lets any aggrieved person file a complaint with the state authority, and Section 18(3) makes a promoter who fails other obligations under the Act liable to compensate you. See how to file a RERA complaint.
After handover, most parking disputes are between residents and the association. Raise it in writing with the managing committee first, quoting the agreement and bye-laws. Our page on rights of housing society members explains what you can ask for. If money paid for a slot is at stake, a property lawyer can advise on recovery; you can find real estate advocates in Noida through LegalFirms.
Frequently asked questions
Can I be forced to pay separately for stilt parking?
Under Maharashtra's MOFA, the Supreme Court held in Nahalchand (2010) that the promoter cannot sell stilt parking, but may recover its cost as a common area, shared among buyers in proportion to each flat's carpet area. In other states the answer depends on local law and the agreement, so check what the charge is for and whether your state's law allows it.
Can my housing society reallocate my parking slot?
It depends on how the slot was given to you and on the society's or association's bye-laws. Ask the committee for the written resolution and the rule it relies on, and compare them with your agreement before you respond.
Is open parking in the compound a common area?
That depends on the sanctioned plan and your state's law. Where open parking forms part of the common areas, RERA requires the promoter to convey undivided proportionate title in common areas to the association, and Uttar Pradesh law bars the transfer or partition of common areas. Check the parking plan attached to the sanctioned layout. How individual open slots are allotted among residents is usually set by the association's bye-laws.
Does a garage count as part of my flat's carpet area?
RERA's carpet area definition in Section 2(k) covers the net usable floor area of the apartment, excluding external walls, service shafts and exclusive balconies or terraces. A garage sits outside the apartment itself. If your agreement includes a garage, it should be described and priced as a separate item.
Work out the cost for your state: the stamp duty and registration calculator shows each charge with its source and date.
Check the developer before you book: 3,322 developers with RERA-registered projects in Mumbai Suburban district and 6,417 developers with RERA-registered projects in Pune district, from the Maharashtra RERA register, with registration numbers and the official page for each project.
Legal Drive and LegalFirms.in are run by Bitola Industries, which also runs Infratyke. We link to them where it helps with the step being described.
Sources
- Supreme Court of India, Nahalchand Laloochand Pvt Ltd v Panchali Co-operative Housing Society Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 2544 of 2010, 31 August 2010 Supreme Court of India ↗
- Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, Sections 2(k), 11(4)(f), 14(2), 17(1), 18(3), 31 (India Code) India Code ↗
- Uttar Pradesh Apartment (Promotion of Construction, Ownership and Maintenance) Act, 2010, Sections 5(4), 25(1) (India Code) India Code ↗
- Unified Building Bye Laws for Delhi 2016, clause 1.4.111 (DDA compendium) Delhi Development Authority ↗
- Income Tax Department, text of section 194-IA, Income-tax Act, 1961; CBDT Form 141 FAQs, 2026 Income Tax Department ↗
Rishabh Bitola is the founder of Infratyke, the real estate lead marketplace operated by Bitola Industries Pvt Ltd, which connects people looking to buy, rent or sell property in India with local agents.