Going to a Consumer Commission Over a Property Dispute
A home buyer can file a consumer complaint against a builder because section 2(42) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 includes housing construction in the definition of service. Delayed possession and failure to get an occupation certificate have been held to be deficiency in service. File within two years of the cause of action, in the District, State or National Commission depending on the amount paid.
| District Commission | Consideration paid up to Rs 50 lakh (Jurisdiction Rules, 2021) |
|---|---|
| State Commission | Above Rs 50 lakh up to Rs 2 crore |
| National Commission | Above Rs 2 crore |
| Time limit to file | Two years from the cause of action, delay condonable for sufficient cause (s.69) |
| District fee | Nil up to Rs 5 lakh; Rs 1,000 for Rs 20 lakh to Rs 50 lakh (December 2022 amendment, as reported) |
In this guide
- Is a home buyer a "consumer" against a builder?
- Consumer commission or RERA: which should you choose?
- Which commission hears your complaint?
- What does it cost to file?
- Is there a deadline?
- What have commissions and courts awarded?
- How to file a consumer complaint against a builder: step by step
- Where to get help
- Frequently asked questions
Home buyers can take a builder to a consumer commission as well as, or instead of, RERA. This guide explains when a property dispute belongs in a consumer commission, how to work out which commission, and what to expect.
Is a home buyer a "consumer" against a builder?
The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (Act No. 35 of 2019) defines "service" in section 2(42), and the definition expressly includes "housing construction". A builder who takes your money to build a flat is providing a service, so failures in that service can be taken to a consumer commission.
The complaint is usually framed as "deficiency" in service. Section 2(11) defines deficiency as any fault, imperfection, shortcoming or inadequacy in the quality, nature and manner of performance. The Supreme Court has applied this to housing in several cases:
- Delay in possession. In Wg Cdr Arifur Rahman Khan v DLF Southern Homes (24 August 2020), failure to deliver within the contractual period was held to be deficiency of service. The court said consumer fora are not bound by an unfair nominal compensation clause (there, Rs 5 per sq ft per month) and may award just and reasonable compensation. It also held that signing the conveyance deed does not bar a delay compensation claim, though buyers who settled voluntarily and later transferees were excluded.
- No occupation certificate. In Samruddhi Co-operative Housing Society v Mumbai Mahalaxmi Construction (11 January 2022), the court held "the failure of the respondent to obtain the occupation certificate is a deficiency in service". Without the certificate, the society's members paid property tax about 25% higher and water charges about 50% higher than normal.
- One-sided agreements. In Pioneer Urban Land v Govindan Raghavan (2 April 2019), the builder could charge 18% a year on late instalments while paying the buyer only 9% for late possession. The court held such one-sided clauses to be an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, and said a term is not final and binding where buyers had no option but to sign the builder's standard form.
Consumer commission or RERA: which should you choose?
You do not have to choose RERA. In Imperia Structures v Anil Patni (2 November 2020), the Supreme Court held that section 79 of the RERA Act bars only civil courts, and a consumer commission is not a civil court. Reading section 88 of RERA and the words "without prejudice to any other remedy available" in section 18, the court said "a choice or discretion is given to the allottee". The remedies are concurrent.
| Point | Consumer commission | RERA |
|---|---|---|
| Law | Consumer Protection Act, 2019 | RERA Act, 2016 and state rules |
| Which forum | District, State or National, by amount paid | State Authority or adjudicating officer |
| Time limit | Two years, condonable (s.69) | Check your state RERA rules |
| Interest rate | Fixed by the commission on the facts | Prescribed by state rules (for example Haryana Rule 15) |
| Projects covered | Any housing construction service | Projects that need registration under s.3 |
A consumer commission can be the practical choice where the dispute is outside RERA's scope or the builder's agreement is grossly one-sided. For the RERA route, see how to file a RERA complaint.
Which commission hears your complaint?
Pecuniary jurisdiction comes from the Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021, notified as G.S.R. 912(E) on 30 December 2021. The test is the value of goods or services "paid as consideration". For a flat, that means the amount you have actually paid, not the total agreed price and not the compensation you are claiming.
- Up to Rs 50 lakh paid: District Commission.
- Above Rs 50 lakh and up to Rs 2 crore: State Commission.
- Above Rs 2 crore: National Commission.
On territory, section 34(2)(d) lets you file in the District Commission within whose limits you reside or personally work for gain. You do not have to file where the project is. The proviso to section 35(1) allows electronic filing in the prescribed manner.
What does it cost to file?
After the December 2022 amendment to rule 7 of the Consumer Protection (Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions) Rules, 2020, as reported by DT Next on 30 December 2022, the fees are:
| Consideration paid | Commission | Fee |
|---|---|---|
| Up to Rs 5 lakh | District | Nil |
| Above Rs 5 lakh to Rs 10 lakh | District | Rs 200 |
| Above Rs 10 lakh to Rs 20 lakh | District | Rs 400 |
| Above Rs 20 lakh to Rs 50 lakh | District | Rs 1,000 |
| Above Rs 50 lakh to Rs 1 crore | State | Rs 2,000 |
| Above Rs 1 crore to Rs 2 crore | State | Rs 2,500 |
For National Commission complaints, check the current fee schedule with the Commission before filing.
Is there a deadline?
Section 69(1) says a commission shall not admit a complaint unless it is filed within two years from the date the cause of action arose. Section 69(2) allows a later complaint if you show sufficient cause, and the commission records its reasons for condoning the delay.
In property cases, the cause of action can continue. In Samruddhi (2022), the builder's continuous failure to obtain the occupation certificate was held to be "a continuing wrong", so the complaint was not time-barred. In Pushpa Jagannath Shetty v Sahaj Ankur Realtors (28 February 2025), ongoing letters, meetings and escrow communications between buyers and builder showed "a continuing cause of action", and the Supreme Court called the time-bar finding "ex-facie erroneous". Keep every letter and email, because they can matter on limitation.
What have commissions and courts awarded?
Outcomes depend on the facts, but the reported cases show the range. In Imperia Structures, the Supreme Court upheld the National Commission's refund with 9% simple interest and Rs 50,000 costs per complainant. In Pioneer Urban Land, it upheld 10.7% simple interest a year and refused to cap interest at the agreement's 6% or 9%. In Rajnesh Sharma v Business Park Town Planners (24 September 2025, as reported by ThePrint), it raised the refund interest from 9% to 18% a year, the same rate the builder had charged the buyer for late payments, while noting the builder's rate is not automatically the buyer's rate.
Under section 38(7), a commission should try to decide a complaint within three months where no testing is needed, and five months where analysis or testing is required. These are targets to aim for, not guarantees.
How to file a consumer complaint against a builder: step by step
- Total your payments. Add up the consideration actually paid, with receipts. This fixes the commission and the fee.
- Send a legal notice. State the deficiency (delay, no OC, defects, one-sided terms), the clause of the builder-buyer agreement involved, and the relief you want.
- Document defects. If the issue is quality, record it room by room with dated photos. Our pre-possession snag checklist helps.
- Check the occupation certificate. Ask for a copy. If none exists, read why the occupation certificate matters and add it to your complaint.
- Draft and file. Set out facts in date order, the deficiency, the amount paid, and the reliefs: refund or possession, interest, compensation and costs. File in the commission where you live or work, electronically where available.
- Join with other buyers if the problem is common. A housing society can complain for its members, as in Samruddhi.
- Follow through on appeals. An appeal from a District Commission lies to the State Commission within 45 days, with 50% of the amount ordered deposited (s.41). From the State to the National Commission, and from the National Commission to the Supreme Court, the limit is 30 days, each with a 50% deposit (ss.51(1) and 67).
If your project is in the NCR, the Noida flats and Gurugram flats pages show what else is on the market should you take a refund and buy again.
Where to get help
This guide is general information about Indian consumer law as of November 2026, not legal advice. Fees and filing systems change, and the right reliefs depend on your agreement and payment history. Read the LegalFirms guide on how to file a consumer complaint, or find a consumer protection lawyer for a claim against a builder.
Frequently asked questions
Can I file a consumer complaint against a builder after taking possession?
Yes, in many cases. The Supreme Court held in Arifur Rahman Khan (2020) that executing the conveyance deed does not bar a claim for delay compensation, except for buyers who entered voluntary settlements and later transferees. Defects and the absence of an occupation certificate can also be raised after possession, subject to the two-year limit in section 69 and the continuing wrong principle.
Which commission do I approach if my flat costs Rs 1.2 crore but I have paid Rs 40 lakh?
The District Commission. Under the 2021 Jurisdiction Rules, the test is the value of services paid as consideration, so it is the Rs 40 lakh actually paid that counts, not the Rs 1.2 crore price or the compensation claimed. On the fee table reported after the December 2022 amendment, a claim in the Rs 20 lakh to Rs 50 lakh band carries a fee of Rs 1,000.
Does a clause limiting delay compensation to a small amount bind the commission?
Not if it is unfair. In Arifur Rahman Khan (2020), the Supreme Court said consumer fora are not bound by a nominal compensation clause of Rs 5 per sq ft per month and may award just and reasonable compensation. In Pioneer Urban Land (2019), one-sided clauses in a builder's standard agreement were held to be an unfair trade practice.
Can a housing society go to a consumer commission against the builder?
Yes. In Samruddhi Co-operative Housing Society (2022), the society's complaint over the builder's failure to obtain an occupation certificate reached the Supreme Court, which held the members were consumers entitled to compensation and treated the failure as a continuing wrong. The matter was sent back to the National Commission to decide the amount within three months.
Check the developer before you book: 3,322 developers with RERA-registered projects in Mumbai Suburban district and 481 developers with RERA-registered projects in Gautam Buddha Nagar district, from the Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh RERA registers, with registration numbers and the official page for each project.
LegalFirms.in is run by Bitola Industries, which also runs Infratyke. We link to it where it helps with the step being described.
Sources
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (Act No. 35 of 2019), sections 2(11), 2(42), 34(2)(d), 35(1), 38(7), 41, 51(1), 67, 69 India Code ↗
- Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021, G.S.R. 912(E), 30 December 2021 India Code ↗
- Consumer Protection (Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions) Rules, 2020, rule 7 as amended December 2022 (reported by DT Next, 30 December 2022) India Code ↗
- Supreme Court of India, Imperia Structures Ltd v Anil Patni, [2020] 12 SCR 373, 2 November 2020 Supreme Court of India ↗
- Supreme Court of India, Wg Cdr Arifur Rahman Khan v DLF Southern Homes, [2020] 9 SCR 136, 24 August 2020 Supreme Court of India ↗
- Supreme Court of India, Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Ltd v Govindan Raghavan, CA 12238 of 2018, 2 April 2019 Supreme Court of India ↗
- Supreme Court of India, Samruddhi Co-operative Housing Society v Mumbai Mahalaxmi Construction, CA 4000 of 2019, 11 January 2022 Supreme Court of India ↗
- Supreme Court of India, Pushpa Jagannath Shetty v Sahaj Ankur Realtors, 2025 INSC 294, 28 February 2025 Supreme Court of India ↗
- Supreme Court of India, Rajnesh Sharma v Business Park Town Planners Ltd, 24 September 2025 (reported by ThePrint, 26 September 2025) Supreme Court of India ↗
- Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, sections 18, 79, 88 India Code ↗
Rishabh Bitola is the founder of Infratyke, the real estate lead marketplace operated by Bitola Industries Pvt Ltd, which connects people looking to buy, rent or sell property in India with local agents.